Research Ideas and Outcomes :
Grant Proposal
|
Corresponding author: Michael P. Meredith (mmm@bas.ac.uk)
Received: 02 Apr 2025 | Published: 14 May 2025
© 2025 Michael Meredith, Katharine Hendry, E. Povl Abrahamsen, J. Alexander Brearley, Emma Young, David Munday, Hugh Venables, Anna Hogg, Benjamin Wallis, Katrien Van Landeghem, Filipa Carvalho, Andrew Yool, Amber Annett, Alberto Naveira Garabato, Mark Inall, Katy Sheen, Andrew Fleming, Estelle Dumont, Oskar Głowacki, Carlos Moffat, Neil Fraser, Sarah Gille, Matthew Alford, Rebecca Jackson, Katherine Retallick
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Meredith MP, Hendry K, Abrahamsen EP, Brearley JA, Young E, Munday D, Venables H, Hogg A, Wallis BJ, Van Landeghem K, Carvalho F, Yool A, Annett A, Naveira Garabato A, Inall M, Sheen K, Fleming A, Dumont E, Głowacki O, Moffat C, Fraser N, Gille S, Alford M, Jackson R, Retallick K (2025) Polar Ocean Mixing by Internal Tsunamis (POLOMINTS). Research Ideas and Outcomes 11: e154645. https://doi.org/10.3897/rio.11.e154645
|
|
Mixing of the ocean around Antarctica is a key process that exerts influences over large scales and in multiple ways. By redistributing heat in the ocean, it exerts strong influences on the Antarctic Ice Sheet, with implications for sea level rise globally. Similarly, the redistribution of ocean heat affects the production of sea ice in winter and its melt in summer, with consequences for climate. Mixing also affects the distribution of nutrients in the ocean, with direct impacts on the marine ecosystem and biodiversity and with consequences for fisheries.
It was long thought that mixing of the seas close to Antarctica was predominantly caused by winds, tides and the loss of heat from the ocean especially in winter. However, we recently discovered that when glaciers calve in Antarctica, they can trigger underwater tsunamis. These are large (multi-metre) waves that move rapidly away from the coastline and when they break, they cause sudden bursts of very intense mixing. Simple calculations indicated that the net impact of these underwater tsunamis could be as strong as winds, and much more important than tides, in driving mixing. It was also argued that they are likely to be relevant everywhere that glaciers calve into the sea, including Greenland and across the Arctic. As our ocean and atmosphere continue to heat up, it is very possible that glacier calving will become more frequent and intensify, increasing further the impact of underwater tsunamis on large-scale climate, the cryosphere and ecosystems.
This is an exciting new avenue of scientific investigation and many key questions remain unanswered. We need to know how widespread and frequent the generation of underwater tsunamis is, how far they travel from the coastline before breaking, and how variable this is. We need to measure what impacts the extra mixing has on ocean temperature and nutrient concentrations, and to determine what this means for the cryosphere and ocean productivity. There is a pressing need to include the effects of underwater tsunamis in the computer models that are used for projecting future ocean climate and ecosystem conditions and to determine the feedbacks between climate change and the generation of more underwater tsunamis.
To answer these questions, our project will deploy innovative techniques for measuring the ocean and ice in close proximity to a calving glacier, including robotic underwater vehicles and remotely-piloted aircraft, and cutting-edge deep-learning techniques applied to satellite data. We will use advanced computer simulations to fully understand the causal mechanisms responsible for the creation and spread of the underwater tsunamis and their impacts on ocean climate and marine productivity. We will make our developments in computer simulation available to the whole community of users, for widespread uptake and future use.
This project will have significant benefits for academics seeking to predict the future of Antarctica and its impacts on the rest of the world, for Governments and intergovernmental agencies seeking to understand how best to respond to climate change, and for the curious general public wanting to learn more about the extremes of the planet and why they matter. The fieldwork will be especially photo- and video-genic and will lead to outstanding outreach and impact opportunities, and we will work with media agencies seeking to tell compelling stories about the extremes of the Earth.
ocean mixing, glacier calving, internal waves, internal tsunamis, carbon, biogeochemistry
Transformations of Antarctic shelf waters exert a global climatic influence (
The conventional paradigm has long held that ocean mixing around Antarctica is driven predominantly by winds, tides, and buoyancy forcing. However, it was recently observed that glacier calving can trigger internal tsunami waves, the breaking of which drives bursts of vigorous vertical mixing that strongly homogenise the upper ocean (
The discovery of calving-induced internal tsunamis and their role in mixing was serendipitous, with only a single event observed for a few days. Important questions remain concerning the type and scale of calving most effective in triggering such tsunamis, how widespread they are, how far they propagate, their dependence on oceanographic conditions and fjordic geometries, their climatic, biogeochemical and ecological impacts, and their likely evolution in a warming world. At present, it is unclear even whether this process represents a positive or negative feedback on glacier stability under different conditions of ocean stratification. A systematic, process-orientated project is now needed to answer these questions and to determine how this newly-discovered source of ocean mixing can be represented in regional and large-scale ocean models.
We propose an interdisciplinary project combining intensive dedicated observational campaigns, data mining, Earth Observation (EO) studies, deep-learning techniques and innovative modelling to meet this requirement. Using these techniques, we will address a key overarching goal, which is to determine the key mechanisms of internal tsunamigenesis across a wide range of temporal/spatial scales of glacier calving and ocean conditions and to quantify its impact on mixing, heat and nutrient redistribution, marine productivity and carbon cycling.
This is a very recent and exciting new avenue of interdisciplinary science. The single observation of internal tsunamigenesis by glacier calving made thus far has already generated a high-profile paper and significant media interest and there is now very strong potential for rapid progress. The science we propose here will greatly advance our understanding of, and ability to predict, ocean transformations in regions crucial for climate change, cryosphere loss and ecosystems change. By delivering this science, POLOMINTS will produce three key outputs:-
Large, multidisciplinary challenges require large multidisciplinary projects. The impacts of internal tsunamis on climate and marine productivity will depend on complex interactions between the cryosphere, ocean, biosphere and atmosphere. Determination of these requires multidisciplinary analyses of a wide range of in situ, autonomous and remotely-sensed data, along with sophisticated model analyses and deep-learning techniques. Collaborative work across a large team of specialists is needed to ensure that the model configurations are suitably informed by diverse data and remote-sensing outputs and that fieldwork execution and data interpretation are informed by the modelling. A single integrated project is needed to achieve our objectives, and is beyond the resource scope of smaller funding schemes.
The POLOMINTS outputs will directly benefit a range of academic and wider stakeholders. They will be of significant benefit to scientists seeking enhanced knowledge of ice/ocean interactions in climatically-, biogeochemically- and ecologically-important regions, including some of the most rapidly-changing in the world. We will improve model skill in one of the most poorly-understood components of the Earth system, representing an important pathway to improve our capability for robust future projections. This will include transferring our model parameterisation back to the trunk of the Nucleus for European Modelling of the Ocean (NEMO), which is widely used nationally and internationally for simulations and projections of the ocean, climate and ecosystem. Our project will enable improved contributions to policy-relevant assessments of the role of the polar regions in climate, the cryosphere and ecology, thus helping to improve decision-making concerning mitigation of, and adaptation to, climate change. We anticipate disseminating key findings via UN and Intergovernmental assessments, including the Intergovernmental Panel for Climate Change (IPCC) and the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES). Potential implications relevant to ecosystems conservation and fisheries policy will be disseminated to the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources (CCAMLR). In addition, we will engage with UK policy stakeholders via the All-Party Parliamentary Groups (APPGs) for the Ocean and for Polar Regions, via the annual “State of the Polar Regions” reports for the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, and so on. We will also engage with communications specialists, popular science communicators and documentary makers, many of whom have already shown great interest in this research given its dramatic and videogenic nature; by so doing, we will seek to convey the importance and excitement of what we do to the curious public.
The generation of internal tsunamis by glacier calving is a very recent and exciting discovery, and this is the first opportunity to mobilise a large, multidisciplinary project to investigate it with the specialist equipment and capability required. The urgency for such a project derives from the rapidly-changing nature of the polar environments, which include some of the regions most impacted by climatic warming anywhere in the world. Antarctica is potentially passing a tipping point to a “new normal”, with cryosphere and ocean changes key to this transition (
We have selected Ryder Bay at the Antarctic Peninsula as the dedicated field campaign site (Fig.
(Left panel) Locations of regional (black) and idealised (red) model domains at the West Antarctic Peninsula. (Right panel) Positions for fixed cameras and ocean instrumentation (symbols), plus coverage of boating/underwater robotic vehicle operations (purple) and remotely-piloted aircraft system flights (yellow).
Three science work packages (WPs; Table
# |
Description |
Leaders |
WP1 |
Dynamics of internal tsunami generation |
Inall (SAMS); Sheen (Exeter) |
WP2 |
Physical and biogeochemical impacts |
Carvalho (NOC); Brearley (BAS) |
WP3 |
Large-scale relevance and future evolution |
Young (BAS); Van Landeghem (Bangor) |
WP4 |
Management, synthesis, dissemination, impact |
Meredith, Hendry (BAS) |
WP1: Dynamics of internal tsunami generation will answer the following key questions:
Q1) How does internal tsunami generation depend on calving magnitude and type (waterline, ice-fall, sheet collapse, stack topple, subaqueous, hybrid etc.)?
Q2) How do oceanographic conditions within fjords influence the characteristics of the internal tsunamis generated and how does this vary within and between seasons?
Q3) To what extent is fjord geometry a key influencer on the magnitude and nature of internal tsunamis generated?
Q4) How far do the internal waves generated propagate from the source, how does the internal wave energy decay, and what is the associated dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy?
To answer these questions, we will use fixed cameras (T5) and passive underwater acoustics (T3) to detect and quantify calving events, augmented with routine and reactive RPAS footage (T4), satellite remote sensing (T7) and active acoustic glacier scanning from small boats (T9). The internal wave response to these events will be classified in terms of vertical structure and spectral composition using moorings and continuously-present underwater glider datasets (T3, T2, T10). Internal wave characteristics will also be recovered from flight deviation analysis applied to underwater glider trajectories. Non-linearity, wave decay and dispersion will be determined from mooring data. Idealised modelling (T8) will be informed by observational data (including from data mining; T1) and used to determine how different modes of ice movement induce different modes of pycnocline response; these simulations will then be used to explore causal relationships across a wide range of parameter space. We will use the idealised modelling simulations and glider data to quantify the magnitude of internal wave energy at differing distances from the glacier front, its direction of speed and propagation and the dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy. The findings of WP1 will be used in other analyses (WP2) to determine the consequences of internal tsunamigenesis for vertical and horizontal water property fluxes. The final output of WP1 will be a set of functional relationships derived from observations and fine-resolution modelling that will provide algebraic expressions relating enhanced vertical mixing (in the form of spatio-temporal estimates of vertical eddy diffusivity) as a function of fjord geometry, stratification and calving type/size. These expressions will form the basis of a parameterisation to be employed in the regional and circum-Antarctic model simulations (WP2, WP3).
WP2: Impacts on ocean physics, biogeochemistry and phytoplankton ecology will answer the following key questions:-
Q1) What impact does internal tsunami-induced mixing have on the water column properties, specifically the stratification, mixed layer depth and heat fluxes?
Q2) How does the magnitude of this compare with other (known) generators of mixing, including near-inertial shear from winds and internal tides?
Q3) What are the biological and ecological implications of this mixing for ocean biogeochemistry (fluxes of nutrients into the photic zone) and phytoplankton ecology?
Q4) What are the implications for carbon sequestration into the deeper ocean, below the main thermocline?
To answer these questions, a combination of observational datasets collected during POLOMINTS (T2, T3, T6, T10) will be used alongside regular weekly water column profiling and sampling undertaken at the RaTS site (funded separately; Fig.
WP3: Large-scale relevance and future evolution will use a combination of observations and modelling, informed by outputs from WP1 and WP2, to answer three key questions:-
Q1) How widespread is internal tsunamigenesis by glacier calving?
Q2) What are the large-scale impacts of tsunami-induced mixing on ocean productivity and drawdown of heat and carbon?
Q3) How might changes in calving characteristics modify these impacts in the future as the ocean and atmosphere continue to warm?
To address Q1, we will exploit Synthetic Aperture Radar data from the Sentinel-1 satellite (T7) combined with deep-learning methods to systematically map the circumpolar geographical extent and frequency of large glacier calving events for all of Antarctica. Concurrently, we will mine available oceanographic time series (T1) to ascertain the geographical extent of internal tsunamis associated with identified calving events and to reveal which calving magnitudes are likely to trigger internal tsunamis, with subsequent refinement of the satellite data analysis. The 8-year long satellite data record provides year-round measurement capability, enabling us to:
To address Q2, we will use a numerical modelling approach, combining the tsunami extent and frequency quantified in Q1 together with the new parameterisation of mixing from internal tsunamis developed in WP1 and tested at a regional scale in WP2, to assess the impact of internal tsunamis on Southern Ocean heat and carbon drawdown and on large-scale productivity (T8). This will be achieved through incorporation of the new mechanism for oceanographic mixing in an existing high-resolution (1/12º) NEMO-Medusa model with circumpolar coverage. To address Q3, we will use the enhanced model to quantify the physical and biogeochemical effects of predicted future changes in calving frequency and magnitude, with different simulations conducted to represent an increase in calving as warming continues and glaciers retreat and a decrease in calving as glaciers retreat further to become land-terminating.
WP4. Management, synthesis, dissemination and impact. All investigators and Project Partners will participate in this WP, with the PI assuming overall responsibility for project delivery, risk management, dissemination and generation of impact. Operational responsibility for individual project components, including line management of PDRAs, will be devolved to the relevant Co-Investigators. All-hands meetings will be held monthly via videoconferencing and every six months in person to ensure effective progress towards our objectives, with the meeting location rotating between the investigators’ institutions. We will invite an Advisory Board (composition to be agreed with NERC) to oversee the project progression and help ensure optimal delivery and impact.
Fig.
M1. Successful deployment of fixed observational array (Q4 25); completion of season 1 summer field campaign (Q1 26); summer 2 field campaign (Q1 27); recovery of fixed array (Q1 28).
M2. Collation of all mined datasets for truthing models and enabling historical tsunami-genesis to be investigated around Antarctica (Q2 26).
M3. EO datasets processed and deep-learning algorithm trained (Q1 26); processing of large-area datasets and inclusion in analyses (Q2 27).
M4. Idealised (Q2 26), regional (Q2 27) and circum-Antarctic (Q4 28) models successfully run, with new parameterisation included in latter two.
D1. All new datasets processed, quality controlled and passed to data centres for archiving and dissemination (Q3 28).
D2. Key publications on: (i) historical evidence for calving-induced tsunamigenesis, based on data mining and EO; (ii) dynamics and dependencies of calving-induced tsunamigenesis; (iii) impacts of breaking internal tsunamis on ocean mixing, heat, nutrient and carbon fluxes; (iv) large-area impacts on physical and biogeochemical ocean dynamics; (v) future changes in tsunamigenesis and impacts under different idealised climate scenarios; (vi) overarching paper drawing key findings together, targeted at a high-profile journal. Numerous other papers are anticipated throughout the course of the project.
D3. Model configurations made publicly-available and new parameterisation passed to developers for inclusion in NEMO trunk (Q1 29).
D4. Briefing papers written for Government, APPGs and intergovernmental agencies on relevance of new findings to climate, ecosystem and resource management policy (Q4 27; Q1 29).
D5. Stakeholder connection events with media, academics and policymakers (Q4 26; Q1 29).
WP4 will oversee dissemination activities, ensuring suitable representation at key meetings and conferences and tracking production and delivery of outputs. It will ensure the delivery of new scientific evidence in accessible form to intergovernmental assessment bodies concerned with climate and biodiversity (IPCC, IPBES) to make it available to policymakers. We will work with marine biologists in BAS and beyond to determine the key implications of the science for conservation and fisheries policy; WP4 will ensure accessible material is input to CCAMLR accordingly. We will pro-actively engage with a wide stakeholder community in the UK, including Government and Parliament; this will be achieved via our connections with the All-Party Parliamentary Groups (APPGs) on the Ocean and on the Polar Regions and through the production and dissemination of briefing notes. Our fieldwork will be extremely photo- and video-genic, and we will work with the press offices of the partner institutes to connect with different media interested in reporting the science as it happens, in addition to key new findings; we will use this route to inspire the curious public with the excitement of the science and Antarctica.
Project risks include those inherent in any marine/polar field-based campaigns. The risk of equipment failure/loss in the field will be mitigated by using multiple platforms with overlapping capabilities and by incorporating pre-existing data where possible. The risk of the fieldwork schedule being moved due to operational reasons will be mitigated by the capability to deploy field personnel and equipment by different routes (air, sea) and by leveraging collaborations to help with deployment where practicable. Our heavy use of autonomous technology reduces dependency on large research vessels for many of the techniques to be used. The risk of Ryder Bay being covered in sea ice during key periods is diminishing due to climate change, but cannot be assumed negligible especially in winter; use of the permanently-staffed Rothera Research Station as the launching site for our fieldwork will ensure that the work can be undertaken whenever conditions allow. Having two summer field seasons is not only scientifically important, it will enable lessons to be learned from the first season and methods to be refined. Risks with laboratory/office-based aspects of the programme are low, with tested equipment and procedures to be used. The project requires cutting-edge model development, but the team includes experienced developers and has the MIT general circulation model (MITgcm) and NEMO communities to draw upon for support. With suitable mitigation in place, the chance of successful delivery of POLOMINTS is very high.
T1. Data mining. Given that the existence of calving-induced internal tsunamis is a very recent discovery (
T2. Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs). Four underwater gliders will be deployed (Fig.
T3. Seabed-deployed instrumentation. Ocean moorings and bottom landers (Fig.
T4. Airborne campaigns. During the summer field seasons, we will conduct regular flights with RPAS over the Sheldon Glacier front. These flights will use the BAS autonomous AgEagle eBee X fixed-wing aircraft with a SODA3D optical camera. We have an established photogrammetric workflow to derive surface elevation over ice- or snow-covered terrain. Differences between these derived surfaces will provide a measure of the magnitude of change above sea level and, hence, produce volumetric information on the size of calving events in addition to qualitative information on the locations across the glacier system where calving has occurred.
T5. Fixed-camera array. We will install four fixed cameras at two locations on Stork Ridge, overlooking the Sheldon Glacier front (Fig.
T6. Reactive small boat sampling and laboratory analyses. When the Stork Ridge camera system (T5) identifies a calving event, the local team will deploy in rigid inflatable boats as soon as feasible, with immediate sampling being conducted as close to the glacier as is safe. During the rapid/reactive sampling, profiles of temperature, salinity, fluorescence, dissolved oxygen and turbulent fluxes will be obtained using a hand-deployable MSS90 microstructure sonde (
T7. Deep learning applied to Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imagery. We will apply deep-learning techniques (specifically convolutional neural networks) to satellite-derived SAR data to determine glacier front locations and calving events around Antarctica on unprecedented spatio-temporal scales. For the required training dataset, we will use a combination of publicly-available training datasets (
T8. Numerical Modelling. WPs 1-3 will draw on numerical simulations that span multiple scales, each with distinct capabilities and purposes.
T9. Glacier front mapping from Erebus workboat. During the period of mooring deployment from RRS Sir David Attenborough (SDA; T3), we will use the SDA’s 10-m workboat Erebus to map the front of Sheldon Glacier with a MultiBeam Echosounder (MBES). This will capture the 3D shape of the ice front and the seabed underneath. Given that glacier mass loss due to large calving is affected by the interaction between ocean and ice front (heat transfer, subglacial water flux) and between ice and bed (friction and glacier stress field), the simultaneously-documented shape of the glacier front and adjacent seabed are fundamental variables when assessing the potential for large calving to occur and to impact ocean processes.
T10. Optical fibre cable. POLOMINTS will collaborate with the separately-funded AN-MELT project, which is deploying a 15-km optical fibre cable along the seafloor in Ryder Bay that overlaps with our field programme. Co-I Naveira Garabato is common to both projects and will facilitate this collaboration. This innovative technique combines acoustic and gravity wave noise interferometry techniques with distributed optical fibre dynamic strain sensing (e.g.
This project will use a very small amount of ship time on SDA during resupply missions to Rothera and will use the SDA workboat Erebus in seasons 1 and 2 for glacier front mapping. Request is 1-2 days ship time per year, agreed with NERC as an acceptable level (see SMEs). Some moorings equipment has been requested from NMF via SME and confirmed available; all other equipment and platforms required will be provided by the participating institutes and departments. We will use facilities at Rothera Research Station (including boating and Bonner Laboratory facilities), confirmed available (see OSPQ). This project will use the national High-Performance Computing facilities ARCHER2 and JASMIN, which have been discussed and approved in principle by the relevant consortium lead.
POLOMINTS will advance our understanding of how a remote and rapidly-changing region impacts the Earth System across large scales. In addition to the impacts detailed above (Beneficiaries and WP4), it will leave a legacy well beyond the 5-year timescale of the project. This will include:
NERC Large Grant
Polar Ocean Mixing by Internal Tsunamis (POLOMINTS)
British Antarctic Survey